I think he still cares for her. The way he talks to her makes me believe he still does. Abigail said that his wife was the one who put her out and Johns face couldn’t believe it. She also said that john loved her then and he still does and john doesn’t really deny it. She also said that John looked up at her window with loneliness and he said he has. (Miller 145) I believe he still cares for her but he also cares for his wife and its safer to just stay with his wife rather than give everything up for a teenager.